strategy / seo

Website or Instagram: What Belongs Where?

An Instagram profile, a Facebook page, a Google Business Profile and your own website each have a job of their own. Here is the decision, point by point, for your business.

Open Markdown version

You have been posting on Instagram for three years. The profile has followers, the work looks good, enquiries arrive as direct messages. At some point the question comes up: do you still need a website at all?

You can answer it without playing one platform off against another. Each of these surfaces was built for something specific, and if you walk through six points one at a time, the decision settles itself at every point. That is what follows: per point, what a social profile does well, where its limit sits, and what a page of your own does in the same place.

Who owns the audience and the account?

The account sits with the platform, and that is a matter of the rules it runs on. Meta’s own help pages say that accounts which breach the Community Standards can be disabled, and that someone who thinks a decision was wrong may be able to request a review of it. For Facebook the same help centre spells out what applies in the meantime: while an account is suspended or disabled it is visible to nobody and you cannot use it. There is a 180 day window for an appeal, and after that the deactivation stands permanently.

A profile does something in return that a website does not. It is the place where the conversation with the people who follow you happens, and it puts a new piece of work in front of people who were not searching for you at the time. That is what it was built for, and it is worth using for exactly that.

On your own website everything hangs on the domain, and a domain has a holder. The registry for .at domains puts the role plainly: the holder “has all rights and obligations relating to his .at domain”, holds “the exclusive right of use”, and “none of your domain data can be modified without your approval, nor can the domain be deleted”. Then the practical part: an AuthInfo code moves the domain to another provider, and the current provider has to hand that code over even when invoices are still open.

Four things you can do in half an hour:

  1. Export your content. Instagram has a tool for it. Timing is the thing to watch: Meta’s help pages state that once a profile has been deleted you no longer have access to Instagram’s export tool. So do it now, and once or twice a year after that.
  2. Keep photos and texts with you as well. A folder on your own machine with a backup is enough.
  3. Check whose name the domain is registered under. If an agency is named there, that is the first thing to put right.
  4. Give two people access to every important account. Which accounts those are is the subject of who actually has access to your website.

What happens to a post after a few days?

A feed post reaches the people the feed shows it to, at the moment it shows it. Meta describes the mechanism itself: the system “automatically orders the posts in your feed by predicting what you will find most valuable and relevant”, and that prediction rests on factors “including what and whom you’ve followed, liked or engaged with recently”. The post therefore travels through an order that is assembled for each person separately.

For anything current that is the right mechanism. A new piece of work, the opening hours over a public holiday, a note about Saturday’s market, a short video from the site: that wants to be seen now and not in a fortnight.

A page behaves differently. It sits at one address, and whoever opens that address gets the same answer, today or next spring. So anything somebody will still ask about in three months belongs on a page: what you offer, how you work, what it costs, how to reach you. A usable rule of thumb when you post: if you would still send the content of a post to somebody in six months, it needs a page behind it for the post to link to.

What can a search engine and the map see?

Google describes in its own documentation how pages reach the index. They get found through links: Google reads a link on a page it already knows and arrives at the new one. Whether that works “depends on whether Google’s crawlers can access the site”, and the same page names the case of content that “may not be accessible without logging in to the site”. Then the plain limit from the same source: “Indexing isn’t guaranteed; not every page that Google processes will be indexed.”

That is what the difference comes down to. A public page at an address of its own can be linked to and read. Anything behind a login is out of reach for that route.

A Google Business Profile is the third surface in play here, and for a local business often the most effective one. It has a field of its own for the website: Google writes that “You can share your business’s website with your customers on your Business Profile”, tells you to enter the full URL, and adds “Make sure that Googlebot isn’t blocked on your site.” That field shows how the two pieces are meant to fit: the profile puts you on the map and into local search, the website answers what somebody wants to know next.

One part of this does not apply to every business. Google ties the profile to a condition: a business qualifies if it “has a physical location that customers can visit, or travels to customers where they are”. A rented mailing address that nobody works from “isn’t eligible for a Business Profile” under the same guidelines. A business that works purely online does not have this surface available at all.

How to set the profile up, and what else counts locally, is covered at length in how a small Austrian business gets found on Google locally. The placement is what matters here. Profile for the map, page for the answer.

Where does an enquiry land, and who answers it?

An Instagram professional account has two documented routes for this. Under the public business information you can maintain the business category and contact details, and decide whether they are shown on your profile or hidden. And there is the action button, which Meta’s help pages describe as something you connect to an online service, or to which you add a lead form in order to collect contact information. One limit matters while you plan: only one action button can be on a profile at a time.

A direct message is good for a quick back and forth. One question, one answer, two minutes, done. That is a real advantage, and plenty of enquiries want precisely that.

A form on your own page does four things alongside it, and you set all four:

  • It lands where you put it. A shared mailbox that two people watch does not hang on one person’s phone.
  • You choose the fields. If a quote needs the square metres, the location and a preferred date, ask for those. Then the enquiry arrives complete.
  • It works at 11 at night. Somebody decides on a Sunday evening, sends the enquiry and gets a confirmation with a realistic response time.
  • The phone number and address sit beside it in plain text. Some people want to call, and they want to call now.

A message is a conversation. A form is a record. For a conversation take the message. For something that leads to a quote and still has to make sense in six weeks, take the form.

A website and a social profile set side by side across four rows. Who owns the audience and the account: the domain runs in your name, the account sits with the platform. A post after a few days: the page sits at one address and gives the same answer, the post reaches the people the feed shows it to. What a search engine can see: a public page can be linked to and read, anything behind a login is out of reach. Where an enquiry lands: a form with your fields, phone number and address, or a direct message for a quick back and forth.

So what belongs where?

The decision runs job by job, and it looks like this:

What you want to place Social profile Your own website
Showing new work, this week The right place, the feed is built for what is current As a reference, where the work can be shown permanently
Services and how pricing works As a pointer, with a link to the page This is where it belongs, the same answer for every person
Appearing on the map and in local search Complements the Google Business Profile The address the profile links from its website field
An enquiry on a Sunday evening Direct message for a quick back and forth A form with your fields, phone number and address in plain text
Impressum and privacy policy A pointer to the page The place intended for them
Conversation with the people who follow you This is what a profile is for A newsletter sign-up as a second channel
An address you hold yourself The account sits with the platform The domain runs in your name

Two things show up when you read it through. The split follows shelf life: what is true today goes on the profile, what stays true goes on the page. And the two surfaces point at each other. The profile links the page, the page names the profile, and somebody arriving from a post finds the answer they came for in two clicks.

Do you need a website if Instagram is working?

Yes, and our position on it is simple: every business needs a website, at least a simple one. Including the business that runs entirely on a Google Business Profile and Instagram today.

“Simple” here really does mean simple. Five pages cover most of it, and how many pages a business website actually needs walks through each one. The short version:

  1. Home. What you do, for whom, where.
  2. Services. What you offer, with a price or the logic behind the price.
  3. About. Real names, a real photo, a short history.
  4. Contact. Form, phone number, address, a realistic response time.
  5. The pages the law asks for. Impressum and privacy policy. What Austrian law expects from a business website is set out in the legal requirements for a business website in Austria.

Then the domain in your name, the website field in the Business Profile filled in, and the link on the profile pointing at your home page. That gives you an address that is yours, and it lets the social profile concentrate on what it is good at.

If you would rather not build and maintain that simple setup yourself, that is what we do: we set the pages up, keep them current and look after hosting, updates and backups. The ongoing form of that is a website subscription.

If your website has become a bottleneck, let’s talk.

Get in touch